The Lowdown on… Candle Waxes

It’s Valentine’s Day…a day for romance often accompanied by soft, beautiful candlelight. I hope your candles are pure beeswax. If not, the romance may be replaced by toxic illness later.

There are many types of candles to choose from these days. And there are many that are marketed by good people under the mistaken impression that their candles are “natural” and “sustainable.” Unfortunately, most aren’t.

 

Comparison test between paraffin and beeswax candles

Paraffin vs Beeswax

PARAFFIN is a greyish-black sludge that is a by-product of the petroleum refining process. Toxic chemicals are used to treat, colour and scent paraffin candles. Chemicals normally found in paraffin candles include formaldehyde, toluene, benzene, ethanol and acetone. Add toxic, petroleum based fragrances and colours, and you have a toxic cocktail burning in your home. Breathing the fumes of a paraffin candle has been compared to breathing the fumes of a diesel engine. According to the state of California’s Proposition 65 (Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986), there are at least seven toxins in paraffin candle wax, including benzene, a known carcinogen.The soot from burning paraffin can contain carcinogens, neurotoxins and reproductive toxins. Testing and air chamber analysis by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has found the following compounds in significant quantity in a random group of over 30 candles tested: acetone, benzene, trichlorofluoromethane, carbon disulfide, butanone, trichloroethane, carbon tetrachloride carbon black (soot) particulate matter, trichlo-roethene, tetrachloroethene, tolulene, chlorobenzene, ethylbenzene, styrene, xylene, phenol, cresol, cyclopentene and lead. I’m not a chemist, but according to the EPA, they pose a health hazard with continued exposure over time.

crude oil

Crude oil: this is what paraffin wax is made from

GEL CANDLES are made from mineral oil, a petroleum based product, and polymer resin, a plastic. Synthetic colours and scents are added that when burned produce toxic fumes. Due to the characteristics of the gel, gel candles must be burned in a container. Containers restrict air flow leading to incomplete combustion, introducing pollutants (soot) into the air. Also, because containers may be insufficiently heat-resistant, the heat produced by the candle may cause the glass to shatter.

SOY WAX is not a wax at all, but hydrogenated soybean oil. Soybeans are grown using high intensity farming practices with fertilizers, herbicides, pesticides and chemicals, and the majority are now from genetically modified seeds. Soybean oil is heated to a high temperature (140C – 225C) and then introduced to hydrogen and nickel (a suspected carcinogen) as a catalyst to solidify the oil. Soy wax is naturally a “soft” wax with a low melting point. While container candles, tealights and small tarts may be made entirely of soy, it is extremely difficult to make good pillar candles and votives with 100% soy wax, so paraffin wax is usually added. Synthetic colours and fragrances are also added that, when burned, produce even more toxic fumes.

PALM OIL WAX is not genetically modified and is carcinogen-free, but unfortunately it comes mostly from Malaysia where it contributes to the environmental damage being caused by the enormous growth of palm plantations, decimating the native forests. Palm Oil production is one of the most contentious environmental issues in the world. In the major producing countries of palm oil, tropical forests are cut down in order for palm oil plantations to be put in their place. Between 1990 and 2005 palm plantations rocketed by 1.87 million hectares in Malaysia and by more than 3 million hectares in Indonesia. With the help of data from the UN Food and Agriculture Organization, Lian Pin Koh at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich and David Wilcove of Princeton University found that more than half the palm plantations came at the expense of forests – largely pristine, intact forest in Indonesia and previously logged forest in Malaysia. (You’ll note that the organic virgin red palm oil I use in my Smallbones hemp oil soap & shampoo bar comes from western Africa, where oil palm trees are native and have been grown on family farms for many, many generations.) The palm produces fruits in bunches which are harvested and sent to palm oil mills to undergo sterilization, bunch stripping, oil extraction, oil clarification and purification. This crude palm oil then becomes the raw material for palm oil refineries/chemical companies/manufacturing plants where it is further processed by neutralization (removal of free fatty acids), bleaching (removal of colouring substances) and deodorization (removal of odours and flavours). Synthetic fragrance and dyes are usually added to palm wax candles.

PURE & NATURAL WONDERFUL BEESWAX

beeswax pillarsBeeswax is the only all natural candle wax. It’s a sustainable and renewable resource. When you buy a beeswax candle you’re supporting beekeepers, which means supporting those busy little insects that pollinate food crops and keep the world green naturally. Beeswax candles burn cleaner, brighter, hotter and longer than other candles. When natural golden beeswax burns it gives off a soft glow* and sweetens the room with its natural scent — no artificial scents or colours required! Many people are allergic to the artificial waxes and artificial fragrances common in today’s candles, even in church! Beeswax is non-allergenic and is a natural air cleaner, recommended by the American Lung Association. It’s the best choice for asthma and allergy sufferers. Beeswax candles burn cleanly, don’t drip when properly used, and have long burn times, saving you money. Be sure that the candles you buy are 100% beeswax – some countries allow as little as 10% beeswax in candles labelled as ‘beeswax’.

*The light spectrum emitted from a beeswax candle is the closest of all waxes to natural sunshine

Comments

There are 7 comments for this post.

  1. Can we make every hour earth hour? | Simple, Sustainable, Natural on March 26, 2010 6:35 pm

    [...] at home we sit in the soft glow of candles (beeswax only, please) or olive oil lamps. It’s a good time to contemplate what else we can do to lessen our impact [...]

  2. Finally...evidence that beeswax emits the most negative ions! | Simple, Sustainable, Natural on November 1, 2010 3:16 pm

    [...] For information on the different types of candle wax now used, please see “The Lowdown On…Candle Waxes.” [...]

  3. jimmy on December 25, 2011 3:09 am

    I would really appreciate some links to an EPA report documenting all these toxins you claim are in paraffin. For example, if paraffin is a greyish black sludge, why is it white and, when melted, completely clear?

    I would also like to see links to the claims regarding beeswax. It seems to me that anything you burn is not good for you. Since beeswax is a wax, it’s a hydrocarbon, just like paraffin. Candles will give off soot, which is not good for you at all, so I doubt the American Lung Association would approve of that.

  4. Jane on December 26, 2011 1:36 pm

    Hello Jimmy: Here’s one interesting link: http://www.epa.gov/region8/compliance/nepa/tatdeis/AppendixA_Overview_of_Petroleum_Ref.pdf At the top of page A-7 it finally gets to paraffin wax after all the other stages. It shows some of the stages that get it from oil in the ground to wax; after that it gets bleached, etc., with more chemicals.
    Here’s an EPA link: http://www.epa.gov/nrmrl/pubs/600r01001/600R01001.pdf It’s a long document, “CANDLES AND INCENSE AS POTENTIAL SOURCES OF INDOOR AIR POLLUTION: MARKET ANALYSIS AND LITERATURE REVIEW”. The part about indoor air pollutants in candles begins on page 21.
    Here’s a very interesting study done by Iowa State University to determine how soy wax candles compare with paraffin, but it also includes beeswax, which comes out on top: lib3.dss.go.th/fulltext/Journal/J.AOCS/J…/no…/v.79n8p803-808.pdf/

    Interesting that I can’t find the statement given by the Lung Association any more. I’ve read that the petroleum industry exerted pressure to remove it; I’m not a conspiracy theorist but it is strange. I’ve sent them an e-mail asking about the statement. I’ll post here if I receive an answer. Many websites are quoting the same thing; it is legit.

    And finally, an Australian site: http://www.gmagazine.com.au/features/2576/versus-candles?page=0%2C0

  5. Darrell on February 28, 2012 3:06 pm

    Hiya, thanks for your comment on Head Health Nutter’s blog. I just read this article that you linked and I have another question (sorry, it’s the information professional in me–I always like to verify claims); you mention that the American Lung Association recommends beeswax candles but I cannot find that anywhere for the life of me via a direct source (i.e. from the ALA itself), all I can find are blogs randomly mentioning this “fact”. Do you happen to have a citation? Thanks!

  6. Jane on February 28, 2012 9:24 pm

    Hi Darrell: This one has me flumoxed. I actually DID get it directly from their site! When I went back later to add the link, I couldn’t find it. I wonder…”It is interesting to note that the National Candle Association, the organization that represents the candle industry in the United States, has sent me a letter asking me to cease telling the public about the dangers of paraffin. When the American Lung Association made a similar announcement last year, the NCA threatened them with legal action.” Mike Richards, president and founder of Candleworks, Inc. of Iowa City, Iowa; on Life & Health Library (http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0HKL/is_5_7/ai_66918312/)

    The closest I can now find is “Refrain from burning scented or slow-burning candles that have additives. Look for candles, such as bees wax [sic], that do not contain high levels of pollutants”, said to be from the American Lung Association of Minnesota and quoted on http://www.consumeraffairs.com/recalls/candle_tips.htm in an article titled “10 Candle Tips for Consumers”. I can’t find the original quote on the ALA of Minnesota site, either. You probably noticed on your search that the only thing the Lung Association mentions is to not use scented candles. The use of candles is not mentioned anywhere else now, even when they’re talking about indoor air quality, wood-burning stoves, etc.

    The National Candle Association: I can’t imagine an organization of its size having much influence with the Lung Association, but the NCA is probably supported by the petroleum companies, so who knows? It’s all a mystery to me. All I know is that the ALA did recommend beeswax candles for those who burn candles.

  7. Darrell on March 1, 2012 5:56 pm

    Oooh the plot thickens! I wouldn’t be surprised if some oil/petroleum lobbyist group got them to take down their statement or amend it. Yikes. Well, thank you SO MUCH for doing the research and providing it for me, I can’t tell you how much I appreciate it!

Website Designed By Dreamdare Production Inc.
Contact SmallbonesContact Smallbones StudioRSS FeedFollow on FacebookFollow on Twitter